top of page
Porch 1.png

The Porch Journal

Featured Letter

The Door Can Stay Closed
Website divider only .png

Not every closed door is a tragedy.Sometimes, it is where peace begins.

Website divider only .png

There are some doors we spend years trying to keep open.

We stand in them. We brace our feet against them. We make excuses for the cold coming through. We convince ourselves that if we are patient enough, forgiving enough, quiet enough, understanding enough, the person on the other side will eventually learn how to walk through without hurting us.

And when that person is a parent, we are taught that closing the door is almost unthinkable.

"But that's your mother."
"But that's your father."
"You only get one."
"You'll regret it someday."

Maybe.
Or maybe there are things we regret more.

Maybe we regret how many years we spent abandoning ourselves because we were afraid someone would call us cruel for finally choosing peace.

There is a particular kind of grief that comes with accepting that the parent you needed and the parent you were given may never become the same person.

It isn't the grief of not loving them.
Sometimes that would be easier.

It's loving someone while finally accepting that love has never been enough to make the relationship safe. It's remembering the good moments and refusing to use them as evidence that the painful ones didn't matter. It's wishing things could have been different without pretending that they were.
And sometimes, it's grieving someone who is still very much alive.
There is another grief beneath that one, too.

It is grieving the version of yourself who kept trying.
The child who learned early how to make herself smaller so there would be room for everyone else's feelings. The daughter who kept returning because somewhere inside her was still a little girl convinced that if she could just explain herself better, love harder, forgive faster, need less, or become easier to love, maybe this time she would finally have the mother she had always needed.

She didn't.

And eventually, the woman she became had to stop sending that little girl back to the same door asking for something that had never been waiting behind it.

I think that's the part people don't talk about enough.

You can miss someone and still know they cannot have access to you.
You can remember them fondly and still remember why you left.
You can hope they are healthy. Hope they are happy. Hope life is gentle with them.

And still not invite them back into yours.
Those things can exist together.

For a long time, I thought forgiveness meant eventually finding my way back.
I thought healing would end with some beautiful reconciliation where everyone finally understood everything, apologies were spoken, old wounds were acknowledged, and somehow all the years between us made sense.

But healing didn't look like that.
Healing looked much quieter.

It looked like waking up one day and realizing I wasn't angry anymore. I wasn't waiting for an apology. I wasn't rehearsing conversations that would probably never happen. I wasn't trying to find the perfect combination of words that would finally make someone understand what their choices had cost me.

Maybe you tell the story differently.
I've made peace with that, too.

I no longer need to correct your version of me in order to live honestly inside my own.

You are allowed to remember me as the daughter who walked away.
I am allowed to remember how long she stayed.

I stopped needing you to understand why I left.
And there was an incredible amount of freedom in that.
Because boundaries aren't punishment.
Distance isn't always revenge.

And removing someone's access to you doesn't necessarily mean you hate them.
Sometimes it simply means you finally understood that loving another person should not require continually betraying yourself.

There comes a point when explaining the boundary becomes another way of negotiating it.
So you stop explaining.
And that silence can confuse people.

Some people mistake your silence for an invitation to try the door again. It isn't. Sometimes silence simply means there is nothing left to explain. People sometimes call estrangement sudden because they only noticed the day you finally left. They didn't count the years you stayed. They didn't count the conversations you tried to have, the things you forgave, the excuses you made, or the number of times you went home and convinced yourself that maybe you were asking for too much.

They remember the boundary.
You remember what made it necessary.

The door isn't closed because you're standing behind it waiting for someone to knock hard enough.

You aren't testing them.
You aren't hoping they'll prove how badly they want back inside.
You aren't waiting for the perfect apology.
You simply closed the door.
And then you walked away from it.

Maybe that's what peace actually looks like.
Not hatred.
Not revenge.
Not hoping someone hurts because you once did.
Just acceptance.

Acceptance that someone can be important to your story without being entitled to every chapter that comes next. Acceptance that DNA does not create unlimited access to another human being. Acceptance that forgiveness can happen from opposite sides of a boundary.
And acceptance that sometimes the healthiest relationship you can have with someone is the one you no longer participate in.

There is an uncomfortable truth we rarely say aloud: becoming a parent does not make someone incapable of causing harm.

A title can describe a relationship. It cannot make that relationship healthy.
“Mother” or "Father" is a sacred word to many of us. But a sacred title cannot be used as permanent immunity from accountability.

Being someone's child does not mean remaining available for whatever version of love they are willing to give you.

If you're reading this while carrying guilt about a parent, a sibling, or anyone else whose title has been used as the reason you should keep enduring what hurts you, I hope you'll hear this:
You are allowed to stop auditioning for the relationship you should have been given freely.
You are allowed to stop proving that you tried.
You are allowed to grieve what could have been.
You are allowed to love someone from a distance.
You are allowed to forgive without reconciling.
And you are allowed to build a peaceful life without leaving the door unlocked for everyone who once had a key.

There may still be days when you wonder.
There may be birthdays, holidays, old photographs, familiar songs, or ordinary Tuesday afternoons when something catches you off guard.

You may miss them.
Missing someone doesn't mean the boundary was wrong.
It means there was something there worth grieving.

So grieve it.
Remember what was beautiful.
Tell the truth about what wasn't.
And keep going.

Because eventually you may discover something surprising:
You didn't close the door because you stopped loving them.
You closed it because you finally learned how to love yourself, too.
And if someone happens to find these words someday and sees pieces of themselves reflected here, that's okay.

You may recognize yourself in these words. That doesn't mean they were written for you.
These words are for the person sitting quietly on this porch wondering whether choosing peace made them a bad daughter, a bad son, a bad sibling, or a bad person.
It didn't.

Perhaps the hardest thing to accept is that closing the door doesn't erase the love that once lived behind it.

You may still remember their laugh.
You may still know how they take their coffee.
You may still instinctively reach for your phone when something happens before remembering that you don't call anymore.
You may still love pieces of someone you can no longer safely love up close.

None of that makes you weak.
And none of it requires you to go back.
Love can remain after access ends.

Sometimes the cycle doesn't end with an apology.
Sometimes it doesn't end with forgiveness being accepted, relationships being restored, or families becoming whole again.
Sometimes the cycle ends with one person quietly deciding:
It will not continue through me.

No slammed door.
No final argument.
No audience required.
Just a hand leaving the doorknob.
And a life waiting on the other side.

Maybe one day someone will finally understand why you closed it.
Maybe they never will.

Either way, you don't have to spend the rest of your life standing at the door waiting for understanding to arrive.

The door can stay closed.
You can still be at peace.

— Phoenix A. Solace

Website divider only .png
Thank you for sitting on the porch awhile.
bottom of page